The 2025 summer transfer window was dominated by one thing — strikers. From blockbuster moves to last-minute hijackings, Premier League clubs opened their wallets to secure the most lethal finishers in world football. But eight games into the new season, which of these headline-grabbing forwards have delivered on their price tags, and who’s still finding their feet? Here’s a deep dive into every major striker signing worth over £60 million — and how they’re faring so far.
Joao Pedro – Chelsea
Joao Pedro’s arrival at Chelsea was nothing short of cinematic. Fresh from sun-soaked beaches in Brazil, he made an instant impact by firing the Blues to Club World Cup glory, netting three goals, including one in the final against PSG. His early Premier League form continued that momentum — two goals and two assists in his first three matches under Enzo Maresca.
However, the spark has dimmed. Since scoring in a 2–0 victory over Fulham, Pedro has gone nine matches without a goal for club or country. His struggles stem partly from playing out of position; he thrives behind a central striker like Liam Delap, who’s been sidelined with injury. The talent is clear — but consistency is missing.
Grade: C+
Benjamin Šeško – Manchester United
Benjamin Šeško’s transfer saga had shades of classic Premier League drama. Just when a Newcastle move seemed imminent, Manchester United swooped in, securing the Slovenian forward from RB Leipzig for £74 million. New boss Rúben Amorim has eased him into life at Old Trafford, handing him sporadic minutes before his first start in a shock Carabao Cup defeat to Grimsby Town.
Since then, Šeško has begun to settle, contributing two goals from four league starts. Though still adjusting to the physicality of English football, his intelligent movement and aerial prowess are promising signs that United’s investment could soon pay off.
Grade: B
Nick Woltemade – Newcastle United
Newcastle’s summer window was nearly a disaster — top targets slipped away, and Alexander Isak’s looming departure cast a shadow over Tyneside. But Eddie Howe’s patience paid off when the Magpies splashed £69 million to land Nick Woltemade from Stuttgart. The young German has repaid that faith handsomely.
With five goals in eight appearances across all competitions — including four in his first five Premier League matches — Woltemade has quickly become a fan favorite. His cheeky finish against Brighton showcased his composure, and his performances suggest Newcastle might not miss Isak as much as feared.
Grade: A-
Viktor Gyökeres – Arsenal
Seen as the final piece in Mikel Arteta’s title puzzle, Viktor Gyökeres arrived at Arsenal with sky-high expectations following his prolific spell at Sporting CP. His debut goal in a 5–0 demolition of Leeds hinted at great things, but adaptation to the Premier League has proven tougher than expected.
At times, the Swedish international has appeared out of sync with Arsenal’s intricate attacking rhythm, though his recent Champions League brace could mark a turning point. If he finds his groove, Gyökeres could yet be the talisman Arsenal fans hoped for.
Grade: B-
Hugo Ekitiké – Liverpool
Liverpool’s first striking splash of the summer came in the form of Hugo Ekitiké, a £79 million signing from Eintracht Frankfurt. The French forward hit the ground running with goals in his first three matches, immediately endearing himself to the Anfield faithful.
However, a red card in a League Cup clash against Southampton disrupted his momentum, and he’s since struggled for regular starts amid Arne Slot’s tactical rotations. Still, his recent Champions League goal suggests the 23-year-old could soon reignite his early-season spark.
Grade: B
Alexander Isak – Liverpool
Liverpool’s biggest statement signing — and the most expensive transfer in British history at £125 million — was Alexander Isak’s arrival from Newcastle. Yet, the Swedish star’s start at Anfield has been underwhelming. Despite scoring once in the EFL Cup, Isak remains winless in a Premier League match he’s started for Liverpool.
A lack of pre-season preparation has hampered his rhythm, and while his technical quality is undeniable, his overall impact has been minimal. With pressure mounting, Isak needs to find form fast to justify his record-breaking fee.
Grade: C-
Final Verdict
This summer’s striker spree has offered a mixed bag. While Woltemade and Šeško have impressed with their early promise, others like Pedro and Isak are still searching for consistency. With months of football still ahead, these early grades could yet change — but for now, only a few of these big-money gambles are truly paying off.
