Jamie Carragher has raised concerns for Newcastle United, suggesting that star striker Alexander Isak may have reached a level beyond what the Magpies can offer. After a record-breaking season and with Liverpool circling, Isak’s future appears increasingly uncertain — and Carragher believes Newcastle could be facing a familiar and uncomfortable scenario.
Isak’s Rise Sparks Transfer Storm
Alexander Isak enjoyed a sensational 2024/25 Premier League campaign, netting a personal best of 23 goals — second only to Mohamed Salah. His performances not only helped Newcastle secure Champions League qualification but also solidified his reputation as one of Europe’s most promising forwards.
However, Isak’s ambitions now appear to lie beyond Tyneside. Reports suggest the Swedish international has expressed his desire to leave, with reigning champions Liverpool showing strong interest. While Newcastle would be reluctant to part ways with their talisman, the pressure from elite clubs — and the player’s own aspirations — could make a transfer inevitable.
Carragher Sees Parallels with Gerrard’s Liverpool
Speaking on The Overlap, former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher compared Isak’s situation to that of Steven Gerrard during his prime years at Anfield. Carragher explained how top-tier players can sometimes surpass the collective level of their team, creating a natural tension between loyalty and ambition.
Sometimes a player outgrows the team, you’re a team that’s fighting for the Champions League, but he’s someone who could play for a team that wins it.
Jamie Carragher
He noted that while Liverpool were fortunate to keep Gerrard due to his deep personal ties to the club, Newcastle may not have that same advantage with Isak.
Criticism Over Transfer Conduct
Carragher didn’t stop at talent alone — he also took issue with how some players, including Isak, reportedly handle transfer situations. He criticized tactics such as feigning injury or skipping training to force a move.
That club brought you in, pays your wages, and the fans treat you like a god, get wanting to move on, but the way you do it matters.
Jamie Carragher
While he acknowledged Isak’s desire to compete at the highest level, Carragher warned that poor conduct during a potential exit could tarnish the striker’s reputation among the Newcastle faithful.
Newcastle’s Next Steps — and Liverpool’s Looming Bid
With Yoane Wissa rumored to be on Newcastle’s radar as a potential replacement, the Magpies may be preparing for life without their star striker. Once a suitable successor is lined up, Liverpool are expected to return with an improved offer — reportedly over £110 million — in a bid to seal the deal for Isak.
Whether Newcastle can convince him to stay, or manage a graceful departure, remains to be seen. Either way, Carragher’s warning suggests the club may be entering a pivotal chapter in its rebuild.
