United’s Risky Call: Amorim’s Decision to Offload Garnacho Raises Eyebrows Ahead of 2025/26 Season
As the countdown to the 2025/26 Premier League season continues, Manchester United’s summer transfer strategy is taking shape—though not without controversy. With Marcus Rashford already sealing a loan move to Barcelona, manager Rúben Amorim appears to be reshaping his attacking options. But his reported decision to show Alejandro Garnacho the exit door could prove to be a bold move with dangerous consequences.
Garnacho: A Spark That Lit Up Old Trafford
Alejandro Garnacho has become a fan favorite at Old Trafford, known for his explosive style, fearless runs, and highlight-reel goals. Under former boss Erik ten Hag, the 21-year-old Argentine winger became a crowd-puller—none more so than with his stunning overhead kick against Everton, a moment etched in recent club folklore.
Despite being one of United’s most exciting young talents, Amorim appears to have told Garnacho to find a new club. The reason remains unclear—disciplinary issues, tactical reshuffling, or personal disagreements have all been speculated. But letting go of a player with 21 goals and 13 assists in 104 appearances seems, on the surface, like a questionable move.
Amorim’s Ruthless Overhaul: Four Wingers Set to Depart
Garnacho isn’t alone on the chopping block. Amorim has also reportedly deemed Jadon Sancho, Antony, and Rashford surplus to requirements. That’s four natural wingers potentially leaving the club in one window—a staggering reshuffle.
With United reportedly slashing Garnacho’s asking price from £70 million to £40 million, there seems to be an urgency to part ways. Yet such haste, especially without clear replacements lined up, could leave United dangerously light in attacking options.
Transfer Inactivity Deepens the Dilemma
Manchester United’s incoming business has been underwhelming so far. Aside from teenage prospects Diego Leon and Enzo Kana-Biyik, the club has only signed Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo—solid additions, but not the type to strike fear into Premier League defenses.
In this context, offloading a proven performer like Garnacho—who not only contributes but excites—feels particularly risky.
Garnacho by the Numbers: Still Among United’s Best
Statistically, Garnacho stacks up impressively. His shot accuracy last season was a sharp 66.7%, and he consistently forced defenders onto the back foot with his direct, aggressive play. Over three seasons, his pass completion rate rarely dipped below 80%, showing he’s not just flashy—he’s effective.
Though he does struggle in defensive duels, that’s hardly unusual for a winger. What matters is his offensive threat, and in that department, Garnacho delivers. He boasts the highest expected goals (xG) figure at the club—9.11—surpassing even Bruno Fernandes when excluding penalties.
A Clash of Vision or Personality?
The growing belief is that Amorim and Garnacho’s disconnect may stem from a personality clash or a difference in footballing philosophy. Sir Alex Ferguson famously dealt with strong personalities while maintaining dominance—something Amorim has yet to prove.
Without the trophy cabinet or tenure to back up such sweeping decisions, Amorim could be setting himself up for scrutiny—especially if Garnacho thrives elsewhere.
Final Thought: Selling Garnacho May Haunt Amorim
If Garnacho is indeed forced out, it may be a moment United regret for years to come. At just 21, he has the stats, the skill, and the star potential. Unless Amorim has a masterstroke in mind, allowing Garnacho to walk could be remembered not as a calculated decision—but a costly mistake.
